I'm VP of Learning & Development at an industrial equipment maker with sites in the US, Brazil and India. Our fiscal year runs April to March. FP&A says we're over budget and wants an explanation or second-half cuts at the CFO's review on December 2. Below are FP&A's email, our first-half spend export, a note from our finance partner and a message from our India lead.
Please give me:
1. Are we really over budget? A two-sentence answer.
2. A corrected first-half table in US dollars, showing each change you made and why.
3. Is the full-year forecast right? If not, what's wrong with how it was worked out.
4. What I should say to the CFO, in three or four lines.
The CFO will check every number, so show your arithmetic. Check currencies, separate money spent from money committed, separate one-off costs from ongoing ones, and flag anything not yet posted. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
[1] Email from Rahul Mehta, FP&A
Subject: L&D mid-year review, Dec 2
Dana, L&D's first-half spend is $6.2M against a $5.5M budget, 13% over. On this run-rate the full year lands at $12.4M against $11.0M. Please explain at the Dec 2 review or bring $1.4M of second-half cuts.
[2] ERP export: L&D spend, April to September (millions)
| Cost centre | Currency of actual | H1 actual | H1 budget (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| US plants | USD | 2.4 | 2.5 |
| Brazil plants | BRL | 1.5 | 0.4 |
| India plants | USD | 0.6 | 0.7 |
| Corporate leadership programmes | USD | 1.7 | 1.9 |
| Total | | 6.2 | 5.5 |
Plan exchange rate: BRL 5.0 = USD 1.
India: September not yet posted.
[3] Note from Sam Ortiz, L&D finance partner
Two things in the H1 numbers: Corporate includes a $0.6M purchase order for the February 2027 leadership academy (committed, not yet invoiced). US plants includes $0.5M for the one-time LMS migration, finished in July.
[4] Teams message from Priya Nair, L&D lead, India
September invoices are about $0.1M. They'll post next week.