A Head of Apprenticeships at a 20,000-person rail equipment maker checks a draft ESG headline against her own data and sends the board committee a page it can rely on, with any AI chat her company allows.
A proud draft headline, a cohort export, a funding total, a college's pass rate and a short HR note. Each looks fine alone. Read together, the headline doesn't hold.
Here the AI checks a page that will go into public reporting. The prompt asks for numbers you can defend.
Use the AI tool your company approves: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
Copy the prompt and the five fictional inputs from the appendix into one message.
Check each number against its input yourself. Then keep what the committee needs and decide what you'll commit to.
I'm Head of Apprenticeships at a rail equipment manufacturer with about 20,000 people in the UK, Germany and Canada. I'm writing the one-page apprenticeship update for our board's ESG committee on December 3. Below are our sustainability lead's email with a draft headline, our cohort data, finance's funding summary, a college partner's report and a note from HR.
Please give me:
A board committee will rely on this, so every number must be one I can defend. Check what each number counts, whether totals add things twice or mix currencies, and whether a rate uses the right group. If something is unknown, say "Unknown". Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
Exactly as it came back, not edited. Read it the way Hannah did: check each point against the source it cites.
No. Both halves of it are wrong.
Corrected headline (every number traceable to [2]): "In 2026, 156 apprentices completed their three-year programme, and 576 more are currently in training." A: completion rate
(576 = 271 + 305. Please confirm the date of the export so "currently" can be given as "as of [date]".)
| Cohort | Started | Completed | Still in training | Left without completing | Kept on | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 (finished 2026) | 240 | 156 | 0 | 84 (240 − 156 − 0) | Unknown | [2]; kept on: [5] |
| 2024 (in year 2 of 3) | 290 | 0 (not due yet) | 271 | 19 (290 − 271) | n/a | [2] |
| 2025 (in year 1 of 3) | 312 | 0 (not due yet) | 305 | 7 (312 − 305) | n/a | [2] |
Rates you can defend:
About Northgate's "98% pass rate" [4]: this uses the wrong group. 98% is 41 of the 42 who sat the exam. Northgate's cohort with us is 60 apprentices, so 41 / 60 = 68% of that cohort passed. For the other 18 the exam outcome is Unknown: they didn't sit it, or the reason isn't given. This is also one college's certification exam in Canada. It isn't a programme completion rate. The inputs also don't show which of our cohorts the 60 belong to, so don't combine it with the figures in [2] or use it as a company-wide figure. found
| Country | Public funding 2026 | Source |
|---|---|---|
| UK | £2.1M apprenticeship levy funds drawn (this includes the £0.9M of college partner fees, which are paid from the levy account) | [3] and its footnote |
| Germany | €0.6M state training grant | [3] |
| Canada | CA$0.4M apprenticeship grant | [3] |
Two errors in finance's "Total public funding: 4.0M":
A single total is Unknown from these inputs. To give one, finance would need to convert the euros and Canadian dollars at a stated exchange rate and date, using £2.1M (not £3.0M) for the UK. Until then, show the three figures separately as above.
One point to check with finance before the board sees this: whether the board should read UK levy draws as "public funding" in the same sense as the German and Canadian grants. The inputs only label them that way and give no further detail.
| Claim | Status | What you'd need |
|---|---|---|
| "Every apprentice is guaranteed a job" | Not supported | A written company policy guaranteeing roles in all three countries. The inputs only show about 90% of German finishers offered roles. |
| How many apprentices were kept on, or a retention rate | Unknown | Offers made and accepted in the UK, Germany and Canada for the 156 finishers, plus tracking beyond the first month as employees (not done today [5]). |
| A company-wide job-offer rate | Unknown | Finisher counts by country and offer counts from the UK and Canada. Germany's "about 90%" needs the exact count behind it. |
| Number of apprentices trained in 2026 | Unknown as a single figure | The export date, whether a 2026 cohort started, and when in 2026 the 2023 cohort finished. Use completed (156) and in training (576) instead. |
| A "98% pass rate" | Misleading | The fair figure is 41 of 60 (68%) for Northgate's cohort. You'd also need to know why 18 didn't sit the exam and which of our cohorts they belong to. |
| Completion rates for the 2024 and 2025 cohorts | Too early | Wait until those cohorts finish (2027 and 2028, given the three-year programme). |
| Why 84 of the 2023 cohort didn't complete | Unknown | Leaver reasons from the apprenticeship system or HR. Expect the committee to ask about this, since it is about a third of the cohort. C: say it first |
| A single public funding total | Unknown | Exchange rates and a date from finance, and removing the double-counted £0.9M. |
| Country split of the cohorts | Unknown | The export broken down by country. Without it, neither the German offer rate nor Northgate's figures can be connected to the pipeline. |
Before Nov 26: ask Claire to drop the job-guarantee line, ask finance for a corrected funding table, and ask HR in the UK and Canada for finisher and offer counts.
Claude found every planted problem. Hannah's edits are about what a board committee should see and what she's willing to commit to.
Use it for any page a board, auditor or regulator will rely on: ESG reports, annual reviews, public commitments.
I'm the [your role] at a [industry] company with about [number] people in [countries]. I'm writing [the page] for [the board committee or audience] on [date]. Below are [the draft text and the data behind it].
Please give me: 1. Is the draft headline accurate? Answer yes or no, then give a corrected headline. 2. [The main numbers], with the input each number comes from. 3. [Any money figures], shown correctly. 4. What we can't claim yet, and what I'd need to claim it.
A board committee will rely on this, so every number must be one I can defend. Check what each number counts, whether totals add things twice or mix currencies, and whether a rate uses the right group. If something is unknown, say "Unknown". Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
Copy the prompt, then all five inputs, into one message in a new chat. Everything here is fictional and safe to paste.
I'm Head of Apprenticeships at a rail equipment manufacturer with about 20,000 people in the UK, Germany and Canada. I'm writing the one-page apprenticeship update for our board's ESG committee on December 3. Below are our sustainability lead's email with a draft headline, our cohort data, finance's funding summary, a college partner's report and a note from HR. Please give me: 1. Is the draft headline accurate? Answer yes or no, then give a corrected headline. 2. The apprentice pipeline, from started to completed to kept on, with the input each number comes from. 3. Public funding, shown correctly. 4. What we can't claim yet, and what I'd need to claim it. A board committee will rely on this, so every number must be one I can defend. Check what each number counts, whether totals add things twice or mix currencies, and whether a rate uses the right group. If something is unknown, say "Unknown". Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs. [1] Email from Claire Dunmore, Head of Sustainability Subject: Apprentice page for the ESG committee, Dec 3 Hannah, I need your one-page apprenticeship update by Nov 26. Comms has drafted the headline: "In 2026 we trained 312 apprentices, and every apprentice is guaranteed a job." Can you confirm the numbers and add funding? [2] Cohort export from the apprenticeship system | Cohort (start year) | Programme length | Started | Completed | Still in training | |---|---|---|---|---| | 2023 | 3 years | 240 | 156 | 0 | | 2024 | 3 years | 290 | 0 | 271 | | 2025 | 3 years | 312 | 0 | 305 | Note: the 2023 cohort finished in 2026. [3] Finance: public funding, 2026 - UK apprenticeship levy funds drawn: £2.1M - College partner fees (UK): £0.9M - Germany state training grant: €0.6M - Canada apprenticeship grant: CA$0.4M - Total public funding: 4.0M Footnote: UK college partner fees are paid from the levy account. [4] Report from Northgate College (Canada partner) 2026 certification exams: 98% pass rate! 41 of the 42 apprentices who sat the exam passed. Our cohort with you: 60 apprentices. [5] Teams message from Jonas Becker, HR Germany On retention: we don't track apprentices after their first month as employees. In Germany we offered permanent roles to about 90% of this year's finishers. UK and Canada didn't send figures.I'm Head of Apprenticeships at a rail equipment manufacturer with about 20,000 people in the UK, Germany and Canada. I'm writing the one-page apprenticeship update for our board's ESG committee on December 3. Below are our sustainability lead's email with a draft headline, our cohort data, finance's funding summary, a college partner's report and a note from HR.
Please give me:
A board committee will rely on this, so every number must be one I can defend. Check what each number counts, whether totals add things twice or mix currencies, and whether a rate uses the right group. If something is unknown, say "Unknown". Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
Subject: Apprentice page for the ESG committee, Dec 3
Hannah, I need your one-page apprenticeship update by Nov 26. Comms has drafted the headline: "In 2026 we trained 312 apprentices, and every apprentice is guaranteed a job." Can you confirm the numbers and add funding?
| Cohort (start year) | Programme length | Started | Completed | Still in training |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 3 years | 240 | 156 | 0 |
| 2024 | 3 years | 290 | 0 | 271 |
| 2025 | 3 years | 312 | 0 | 305 |
Note: the 2023 cohort finished in 2026.
Footnote: UK college partner fees are paid from the levy account.
2026 certification exams: 98% pass rate! 41 of the 42 apprentices who sat the exam passed. Our cohort with you: 60 apprentices.
On retention: we don't track apprentices after their first month as employees. In Germany we offered permanent roles to about 90% of this year's finishers. UK and Canada didn't send figures.