A VP of Talent & Learning at a 58,000-person manufacturer checks her team's board pre-read against the sources, with any AI chat her company allows.
A confident draft and four sources that tell a more careful story. The draft isn't dishonest. It rounds every number in its own favour.
Here the AI isn't writing. It's checking. The prompt asks it to act like a strict reviewer.
Use the AI tool your company approves: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
Copy the prompt, the draft [A] and sources [B]–[E] from the appendix into one message.
Recalculate two numbers yourself. Then decide what the board sees.
I'm a VP of Talent & Learning at a large manufacturing company. My team drafted the learning page for our board's People Committee pre-read. Before it goes to the CHRO and the board, I need to check it against the source material. Below are the draft [A] and four sources [B]–[E].
Please check every claim in the draft and give me:
Be strict. A board will read this. Recalculate percentages yourself, and check what each number is a percentage of. Don't accept a headline because it sounds positive. If a source doesn't support a claim, say so plainly. Don't add facts that aren't in the sources.
Exactly as it came back, not edited. Read it the way Mei Lin did: check each point against the source it cites.
The draft is not ready for board circulation. Several figures are mathematically correct, but their descriptions are misleading. The two questions explicitly requested by the People Committee are also unanswered.
1. Claim check
| Claim as written [A] | What the sources actually support | Verdict | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| “Leadership pipeline is strong” | No succession-readiness evidence for the top 60 roles. Program participation does not establish bench strength. | Not supported | B, E found |
| “92% of our high-potential leaders completed…in Q3” | 150 of 163 enrolled participants completed (92.0%). Only 150 of 310 identified high-potentials completed (48.4%). | Overstated | B found |
| “Safety training compliance reached 98% across all sites” | 98% compliance among 34 reporting sites. Six acquired sites have no LMS data. | Overstated | B found |
| “Our best result to date” | Reporting-site compliance increased from 96% in Q3 2025 to 98% in Q3 2026. No earlier history or equivalent company-wide comparison is provided. | Not supported | B found |
| “Learning is growing fast: total learning hours rose 35% year over year” | Hours increased from 412,000 to 556,200, or 35.0%. Average headcount also rose from 49,000 to 57,800. Hours per employee increased approximately 14.4%. | Supported | B A: partly |
| “Digital Skills Academy saved $2.1M” | $2.1M is an unverified vendor estimate. Finance reports approximately $0.6M less external training spend YTD, partly attributable to timing and a hiring freeze. Neither figure establishes Academy savings. | Not supported | C found |
| “AI literacy launched to all employees in September” | September pilot covered approximately 4,000 office staff across three APAC countries. 1,150 started the first module (28.8%). Frontline and plant workers are excluded. | Overstated | D found |
| “Positioning Talvora for the next phase of automation” | No evidence of readiness, business outcomes or a company-wide rollout. | Not supported | D |
| “Employees value learning more: learning NPS rose 12 points to +41” | NPS increased from +29 to +41, a 12-point rise. Responses increased from 3,900 to 5,100. The data does not establish a change in sentiment across the workforce. | Overstated | B B: partly |
| “Maintain the 2027 L&D budget at current levels to sustain this momentum” | No 2027 budget figures, cost analysis, funding requirements or demonstrated link between spending and outcomes. | Not supported | B–E C |
Key recalculations
Accelerate completions / all high-potentials
48.4%
150 ÷ 310, not 92%
Sites reporting safety data
85.0%
34 ÷ 40 sites
Learning hours growth per employee
+14.4%
Versus +35.0% total hours
AI pilot participation started
28.8%
1,150 ÷ approximately 4,000
The 98% safety compliance figure cannot be recalculated independently because the source provides neither the number of required completions nor the number achieved. It covers reporting sites only.
2. What's missing
The two most consequential omissions are precisely what the Committee chair asked the team to address.
1. Succession readiness for the top 60 leadership roles [E] found D
The draft provides Accelerate participation and completion, but no evidence about the top 60 positions. Missing information includes ready-now successor coverage, readiness timelines, roles without identified successors, and identified gaps. None can be inferred from the 310 high-potentials.
2. Safety compliance at newly acquired sites [B, E] found D
Six acquired sites in Brazil and India are not yet reporting through the LMS. Their compliance is unknown. The draft should clearly state that 98% applies only to the 34 reporting sites, not all 40 sites.
3. Other material gaps [B–D]
3. Suggested rewrite
This version is shorter than the original draft and retains only supported statements.
Q3 Learning & Development: Board Update
Committee follow-up: Establish succession readiness for the top 60 roles and verify acquired-site safety compliance. The available evidence does not support a 2027 budget recommendation. C
Before submission: The revised page makes the gaps visible, but it cannot fully answer the chair's two questions without additional data. Those two areas should be resolved or explicitly presented as outstanding at the December 9 meeting. The pre-read is due December 1. [E]
ChatGPT caught most of the problems. It half-caught two, and its rewrite dropped one of its own warnings. The rest of Mei Lin's edits are judgment calls.
Use it on any draft that's about to go up: a board paper, a QBR deck, an investor update.
I'm a [your role] at a [industry] company. My team drafted [the document] for [the audience]. Before it goes to [who], I need to check it against the source material. Below are the draft and [number] sources.
Please check every claim in the draft and give me: 1. Claim check (a table: the claim as written, what the sources actually support, a verdict, and which source shows it); 2. What's missing (anything [the audience] asked for, or should know); 3. Suggested rewrite (same length or shorter).
Be strict. [The audience] will read this. Recalculate percentages yourself, and check what each number is a percentage of. Don't accept a headline because it sounds positive. If a source doesn't support a claim, say so plainly. Don't add facts that aren't in the sources.
Copy the prompt, then the draft [A] and sources [B]–[E], into one message in a new chat. Everything here is fictional and safe to paste.
I'm a VP of Talent & Learning at a large manufacturing company. My team drafted the learning page for our board's People Committee pre-read. Before it goes to the CHRO and the board, I need to check it against the source material. Below are the draft [A] and four sources [B]–[E]. Please check every claim in the draft and give me: 1. Claim check — a table with one row per claim: the claim as written, what the sources actually support, a verdict (supported / overstated / not supported), and which source shows it. 2. What's missing — anything the committee asked for, or should know, that the draft leaves out. 3. Suggested rewrite — the same page rewritten so every claim matches the sources, in the same length or shorter. Be strict. A board will read this. Recalculate percentages yourself, and check what each number is a percentage of. Don't accept a headline because it sounds positive. If a source doesn't support a claim, say so plainly. Don't add facts that aren't in the sources. [A] The draft — "Q3 Learning & Development: highlights" (prepared by the L&D analytics team) Q3 Learning & Development: highlights - Leadership pipeline is strong: 92% of our high-potential leaders completed the Accelerate leadership program in Q3. - Safety training compliance reached 98% across all sites, our best result to date. - Learning is growing fast: total learning hours rose 35% year over year. - The Digital Skills Academy saved $2.1M in external training spend this year. - AI literacy launched to all employees in September, positioning Talvora for the next phase of automation. - Employees value learning more: learning Net Promoter Score rose 12 points to +41. Recommendation: maintain the 2027 L&D budget at current levels to sustain this momentum. [B] HRIS / LMS data extract — Q3 2026 (from the analytics team's working file) | Measure | Q3 2025 | Q3 2026 | Note | |---|---|---|---| | High-potentials identified (talent review) | 296 | 310 | | | High-potentials enrolled in Accelerate | 150 | 163 | | | Accelerate completions (of enrolled) | 131 | 150 | | | Sites reporting safety-training data | 38 of 38 | 34 of 40 | 6 acquired sites (Brazil, India) not yet on the LMS | | Safety-training compliance, reporting sites | 96% | 98% | | | Total learning hours | 412,000 | 556,200 | | | Average headcount | 49,000 | 57,800 | Acquisition closed May 2026 | | Learning NPS survey responses | 3,900 | 5,100 | Pulse sent to all employees | | Learning NPS | +29 | +41 | | [C] Email — Finance From: Andre Kowalski, Finance Business Partner, HR Subject: RE: Academy savings number Mei Lin, on the $2.1M: that figure is from the Digital Skills Academy vendor's year-end impact report. We haven't validated it. External training spend in our ledger is down about $0.6M year to date, but some of that is timing and the hiring freeze in H1. I'd be careful putting $2.1M in front of the board as our number. Andre [D] Email — APAC L&D From: Sunil Rao, L&D Lead, APAC Subject: AI literacy — first month Hi Mei Lin, quick update on AI literacy. We opened the pilot in September to office-based staff in Singapore, Japan and Australia, about 4,000 people. 1,150 have started the first module so far. Frontline and plant teams aren't in scope yet; we need translated content and a mobile version first. Happy to share more at the next review. Sunil [E] Note — Corporate Secretary From: Office of the Corporate Secretary Subject: People Committee — Q3 pre-read Reminder that pre-reads for the December 9 People Committee are due December 1. The Committee chair has asked that the L&D section address two questions specifically: (1) how ready is our succession bench for the top 60 leadership roles, and (2) are the newly acquired sites meeting our safety-training standard?I'm a VP of Talent & Learning at a large manufacturing company. My team drafted the learning page for our board's People Committee pre-read. Before it goes to the CHRO and the board, I need to check it against the source material. Below are the draft [A] and four sources [B]–[E].
Please check every claim in the draft and give me:
Be strict. A board will read this. Recalculate percentages yourself, and check what each number is a percentage of. Don't accept a headline because it sounds positive. If a source doesn't support a claim, say so plainly. Don't add facts that aren't in the sources.
Q3 Learning & Development: highlights
Recommendation: maintain the 2027 L&D budget at current levels to sustain this momentum.
| Measure | Q3 2025 | Q3 2026 | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| High-potentials identified (talent review) | 296 | 310 | |
| High-potentials enrolled in Accelerate | 150 | 163 | |
| Accelerate completions (of enrolled) | 131 | 150 | |
| Sites reporting safety-training data | 38 of 38 | 34 of 40 | 6 acquired sites (Brazil, India) not yet on the LMS |
| Safety-training compliance, reporting sites | 96% | 98% | |
| Total learning hours | 412,000 | 556,200 | |
| Average headcount | 49,000 | 57,800 | Acquisition closed May 2026 |
| Learning NPS survey responses | 3,900 | 5,100 | Pulse sent to all employees |
| Learning NPS | +29 | +41 |
From: Andre Kowalski, Finance Business Partner, HR Subject: RE: Academy savings number
Mei Lin, on the $2.1M: that figure is from the Digital Skills Academy vendor's year-end impact report. We haven't validated it. External training spend in our ledger is down about $0.6M year to date, but some of that is timing and the hiring freeze in H1. I'd be careful putting $2.1M in front of the board as our number.
Andre
From: Sunil Rao, L&D Lead, APAC Subject: AI literacy — first month
Hi Mei Lin, quick update on AI literacy. We opened the pilot in September to office-based staff in Singapore, Japan and Australia, about 4,000 people. 1,150 have started the first module so far. Frontline and plant teams aren't in scope yet; we need translated content and a mobile version first. Happy to share more at the next review.
Sunil
From: Office of the Corporate Secretary Subject: People Committee — Q3 pre-read
Reminder that pre-reads for the December 9 People Committee are due December 1. The Committee chair has asked that the L&D section address two questions specifically: (1) how ready is our succession bench for the top 60 leadership roles, and (2) are the newly acquired sites meeting our safety-training standard?