A VP Sales at a 15,000-person electrical equipment maker checks next year's commission plan before the CRO and CHRO sign it, with any AI chat her company allows.
A short email from the CRO, a confident plan summary, the modelling by group, and two notes from sales operations and HR. Every average in the table is right. The claims built on them are another matter.
Here the AI checks a pay plan's claims against its own modelling. The prompt makes it say who every percentage counts.
Use the AI tool your company approves: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
Copy the prompt and the five fictional inputs from the appendix into one message.
Count the days from the announcement to the start date, and look up the weekday of any deadline the AI gives you. Then decide what to lead with.
I'm VP Sales for North America at an electrical equipment manufacturer, with 245 quota-carrying reps in the US and Mexico. Our CRO and CHRO sign off next year's commission plan on Friday, December 18, and we announce it at sales kickoff on Monday, January 11. Today is Monday, December 14. The CRO has asked me to check the plan holds up before they sign. Below are his email, the plan summary, the modelling, a sales operations note and an HR note.
Please give me:
For every percentage, say who it counts and who it leaves out. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so. Don't give legal conclusions: say what needs legal or HR confirmation.
Exactly as it came back, not edited. Read it the way Elena did: check each point against the source it cites.
FY27 commission plan check (for Elena, VP Sales North America)
Arithmetic check: the group averages and totals in the modelling [3] add up. 43 + 135 + 36 = 214 US reps, and with Mexico's 31 that makes 245. FY26 plan total: 43×$112,000 + 135×$56,600 + 36×$68,000 = $14,905,000. FY27 plan total: 43×$136,600 + 135×$57,700 + 36×$58,500 = $15,769,300. The problems are in what the summary [2] claims on top of these figures.
1. Each claim in the summary
| Claim [2] | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accelerators raised from 1.5x to 2x | Doesn't hold as written | [4]: in FY26, 1.5x paid above 100% of quota. In FY27, 1x pays from 100% to 110%, and 2x only above 110%. So between 100% and 110% the rate drops from 1.5x to 1x. 41 US reps finished FY26 in that band. The summary leaves out the threshold change. found |
| New-customer bookings credited at 1.25x | Unverified | It is a plan design statement. Nothing in [3] or [4] shows whether the model applied it, or how many FY26 deals would have qualified. |
| Service: first-year value only, "quotas reduced to match" | Doesn't hold | [4]: about half of service reps' credited bookings were multi-year, average 3 years. Crediting year 1 only gives 0.5 + 0.5×(1/3) = 0.67, so credit falls about a third. Quotas fall only 25%. Attainment becomes 0.67 / 0.75 = 89% of before, so a rep at 100% of quota in FY26 lands at about 89%. Matching the credit cut would need a quota cut of about 33%. found |
| Top performers earn 22% more | Holds only narrowly | $112,000 to $136,600 = +$24,600, +21.96%. Who it counts: the 43 US equipment reps in the top 20% by FY26 bookings, and it is their average. Who it leaves out: service reps and Mexico. "Top 20%" is also unclear: 43 is 20% of all 214 modelled reps, but 24% of the 178 equipment reps the row label names. "Top" means bookings, not margin. Of the 20 US reps with the highest FY26 gross margin, 8 are service reps and all 8 earn less [4]. found |
| 85% of reps earn the same or more | Holds for US only | 182 of 214 = 85.0%. Who it counts: the 214 modelled US reps. Who it leaves out: the 31 Mexico reps (13% of 245), who are not modelled. Across all 245 reps, the share known to earn the same or more is 182 / 245 = 74%. "The same or more" also hides that 135 reps gain only about $1,100 on average. found |
| Cost-neutral, within budget | Doesn't hold | FY27 plan $15.77M against a $15.2M US budget [5]: about $0.57M (3.7%) over. That is US only, and Mexico would be extra. It is +5.8% over the FY26 plan re-run ($14.9M), against a budget set at +2%. It also rests on FY26 deals; FY27 cost moves with FY27 results. found |
| Takes effect Monday, February 1 | Conflicts with notice terms | [5]: reps get 30 days' written notice before a change takes effect. An announcement on January 11 is 21 days before February 1. HR needs to confirm how the notice applies (see 4). found |
There is also an internal inconsistency to reconcile, not a conclusion. 41 reps lose the 1.5x rate on their 100% to 110% band, yet only 3 equipment reps earn less in the model. Possible explanations are the new-customer bonus offsetting the loss, or most of the 41 being top-20% reps, but the inputs don't say. Priya should confirm.
2. Who gains and who loses (US modelled reps only; Mexico unknown)
What the averages hide:
3. Does the plan pay for what we said we want?
The two FY27 priorities are new customers and growing multi-year service agreements [1].
4. What must happen, and who confirms
Before sign-off on Friday, December 18:
Before the announcement on Monday, January 11:
5. Recommendation to Dev and Ruth
Everything above rests only on inputs [1] to [5]. Assumptions are labelled, and legal points are flagged for HR or counsel rather than concluded.
Claude found every planted problem, checked the arithmetic and kept legal points with HR and counsel. Elena's edits check one date and decide what the CRO hears first.
Use it whenever a pay or incentive change is summarised for you in averages: a commission plan, a bonus scheme, a quota change, a territory redesign.
I'm [your role] at a [industry] company, with [how many people] affected by [the plan]. [Who] signs it off on [date], and we announce it on [date]. Today is [date]. Below are [the summary, the modelling, the mechanics, the budget and any notice or legal terms].
Please give me: 1. Each claim in the summary: holds, doesn't hold, or unverified, with the input that shows it. 2. Who gains and who loses, by group, and what the averages hide. 3. Does the plan pay for what we said we want? 4. What must happen before sign-off and before the announcement, and who confirms each item. 5. My recommendation, in five lines or fewer.
For every percentage, say who it counts and who it leaves out. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so. Don't give legal conclusions: say what needs legal or HR confirmation.
Copy the prompt, then all five inputs, into one message in a new chat. Everything here is fictional and safe to paste.
I'm VP Sales for North America at an electrical equipment manufacturer, with 245 quota-carrying reps in the US and Mexico. Our CRO and CHRO sign off next year's commission plan on Friday, December 18, and we announce it at sales kickoff on Monday, January 11. Today is Monday, December 14. The CRO has asked me to check the plan holds up before they sign. Below are his email, the plan summary, the modelling, a sales operations note and an HR note. Please give me: 1. Each claim in the summary: holds, doesn't hold, or unverified, with the input that shows it. 2. Who gains and who loses, by group, and what the averages hide. 3. Does the plan pay for what we said we want next year? 4. What must happen before sign-off and before the announcement, and who confirms each item. 5. My recommendation to the CRO and CHRO, in five lines or fewer. For every percentage, say who it counts and who it leaves out. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so. Don't give legal conclusions: say what needs legal or HR confirmation. [1] Email from Dev Malhotra, CRO Elena, Ben's FY27 commission plan summary is below. Our FY27 priorities are new customers and growing multi-year service agreements. Ruth and I sign it off Friday, and we announce at sales kickoff on Monday, January 11. Can you check it holds up before we sign? [2] FY27 commission plan: summary (Ben Harlow, Sales Compensation) What changes from FY26: - Accelerators raised from 1.5x to 2x. - New-customer bonus: bookings with new customers credited at 1.25x. - Simpler crediting for service agreements: first-year value only (FY26: full contract value, up to 3 years). Service quotas reduced to match. What it does: - Top performers earn 22% more. - 85% of reps earn the same or more. - Cost-neutral: within the FY27 variable pay budget. The plan takes effect at the start of FY27, Monday, February 1. [3] Modelling extract: FY26 deals and quotas, re-run under the FY27 plan (US reps) | Group | Reps | Avg variable pay, FY26 plan | Avg variable pay, FY27 plan | Change | Earn less under FY27 | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Top 20% by FY26 bookings (all equipment reps) | 43 | $112,000 | $136,600 | +22% | 0 | | Other equipment reps | 135 | $56,600 | $57,700 | +2% | 3 | | Aftermarket & service reps | 36 | $68,000 | $58,500 | -14% | 29 | | All modelled | 214 | | | | 32 | Total variable pay: FY26 plan $14.9M; FY27 plan $15.8M. [4] Sales operations note (Priya Nair) - Accelerators: in FY26 the 1.5x rate applied above 100% of quota. In FY27, 1x applies from 100% to 110%, and 2x above 110%. 41 US reps finished FY26 between 100% and 110%. - About half of service reps' FY26 credited bookings were multi-year agreements (average term 3 years). First-year-only crediting cuts their credited bookings by about a third; their quotas are cut 25%. - Of the 20 US reps with the highest FY26 gross margin, 8 are aftermarket & service reps. All 8 earn less under FY27. - Mexico (31 reps) is not modelled yet. Its FY26 data is in a separate CRM; extract due January 8. [5] HR note (Marta Ochoa, HR Business Partner, Sales) - FY27 variable pay budget for US sales: $15.2M (FY26 actual plus 2%). - Our plan terms give reps 30 days' written notice of a plan change before it takes effect. - Mexico: our employment counsel there has not reviewed the plan. Their standing advice is that any change that can lower a rep's commission must be reviewed before it is communicated.I'm VP Sales for North America at an electrical equipment manufacturer, with 245 quota-carrying reps in the US and Mexico. Our CRO and CHRO sign off next year's commission plan on Friday, December 18, and we announce it at sales kickoff on Monday, January 11. Today is Monday, December 14. The CRO has asked me to check the plan holds up before they sign. Below are his email, the plan summary, the modelling, a sales operations note and an HR note.
Please give me:
For every percentage, say who it counts and who it leaves out. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so. Don't give legal conclusions: say what needs legal or HR confirmation.
Elena, Ben's FY27 commission plan summary is below. Our FY27 priorities are new customers and growing multi-year service agreements. Ruth and I sign it off Friday, and we announce at sales kickoff on Monday, January 11. Can you check it holds up before we sign?
What changes from FY26: - Accelerators raised from 1.5x to 2x. - New-customer bonus: bookings with new customers credited at 1.25x. - Simpler crediting for service agreements: first-year value only (FY26: full contract value, up to 3 years). Service quotas reduced to match.
What it does: - Top performers earn 22% more. - 85% of reps earn the same or more. - Cost-neutral: within the FY27 variable pay budget.
The plan takes effect at the start of FY27, Monday, February 1.
| Group | Reps | Avg variable pay, FY26 plan | Avg variable pay, FY27 plan | Change | Earn less under FY27 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top 20% by FY26 bookings (all equipment reps) | 43 | $112,000 | $136,600 | +22% | 0 |
| Other equipment reps | 135 | $56,600 | $57,700 | +2% | 3 |
| Aftermarket & service reps | 36 | $68,000 | $58,500 | -14% | 29 |
| All modelled | 214 | 32 |
Total variable pay: FY26 plan $14.9M; FY27 plan $15.8M.