A VP of Learning & Development at an aerospace manufacturer checks her analyst's roll-up against three regional decks before presenting it to the executive team, with any AI chat her company allows.
One confident slide and the three regional decks behind it. Each regional team told the truth. The roll-up added it up in a way none of them would sign.
Here the AI checks a slide you're about to own. The prompt asks it to read every slide, appendices included.
Use the AI tool your company approves: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
Copy the prompt, the roll-up [B] and the inputs [A] to [F] from the appendix into one message.
Check one date calculation yourself. Then decide what the leadership team must decide, and who owns it.
I'm the VP of Learning & Development at an aerospace manufacturer with about 24,000 people in the US, the UK and France. My analyst built the roll-up slide below from three regional decks. I'm presenting it to our executive leadership team on December 3, and they want one answer: is the workforce certified and ready for a production rate increase on March 1? Before I put my name on this slide, I need you to check it.
Please give me:
Be skeptical. Read every slide, including the appendices. Check that numbers measure the same thing before you combine or compare them, check what each trend is compared against, and check dates and lead times against the deadline. If something is missing, say it's missing. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
Exactly as it came back, not edited. Read it the way Claire did: check each point against the source it cites.
Before you put your name on this slide, I'd change it substantially. The 91% headline is built on an estimated number. It combines three regions that each define "certified" differently. And it doesn't answer the question the leadership team asked, which is whether 600 more certified structures assemblers will be in place by March 1. Going by the inputs, the answer is no, not on the current plan.
| Claim on the slide | What the regional decks actually support | Source |
|---|---|---|
| "21,730 of 24,000 employees certified = 91%" | Not supported. Reported certified counts are US 11,400 + UK 5,880 + France 3,204 = 20,484. The 21,730 includes 4,450 for France, which comes from Ravi's note "89% x 5,000". That applies the 89% from two sites to all 5,000 France employees, including Saint-Nazaire, which reported nothing. About 1,246 of the "certified" people are therefore an estimate, not a count. Using only reported data, the figure is 20,484 of 22,600 (90.6%), with 1,400 people unknown. The total also adds up three different measures (see the next row). | US slide 2; UK slide 1; FR slides 1, 3, 4; Ravi's note [B] found |
| "Across all regions" (one combined %) | Not like-for-like. US: "all required courses for the role completed in the LMS." UK: "signed off on the job by a qualified skills assessor." France: "training complete + medical fitness + written authorisation from the supervisor." The US measure only checks course completion. The UK and France measures add an on-the-job or authorisation step. One combined % hides that. | US slide 3; UK slide 2; FR slide 2 found |
| "Up 7 points since Q1 (84%)" | The arithmetic roughly works, but the claim misleads. Q1 was US 86%, UK 80%, France 85% (two sites only), which weights to about 84%. Q3 on the same basis is 90.6%, so up about 6.6 points. But: (a) it still mixes three definitions; (b) France's trend covers two of three sites; (c) the US gain was almost all from Q1 to Q2 (86% to 94%) and has since flattened (95%); (d) the UK went down from 86% in Q2 to 84% in Q3. A Q1-to-Q3 line hides that drop. | US slide 4; UK slide 3; FR slide 5 found |
| "US 95% · UK 84% · France 89%" | The US and UK figures match their decks. France 89% covers only Toulouse and Méaulte (3,204 of 3,600). Saint-Nazaire (1,400 people, 28% of France) is "data not yet received." The three figures also measure different things, so ranking them side by side isn't valid. | US slide 2; UK slide 1; FR slides 3, 4 |
| Chart: Q1 84% → Q3 91% | It leaves out Q2, which would show the UK drop, and its Q3 end point uses the extrapolated France number. | As above |
| "380 new assemblers start January 12 to support the rate increase" | The start date is correct, but the bullet leaves out what matters. Operations needs 600, not 380. Certification takes 10 weeks from start date, so people starting January 12 finish around March 23, about three weeks after March 1. Going by the inputs, none of the 380 will be certified by March 1. The other 220 depend on cross-training, and that plan is "not yet finalised." | Ops note [F]; CHRO email [A] |
| "No major risks" | Contradicted by all three regional decks and the Operations note: US NDT inspectors short and expiring with no examiner booked; UK assessor shortage and a 410-person backlog; France site missing; new-hire timing misses March 1; cross-training plan not finalised. | US slide 9 (appendix); UK slide 4; FR slide 4; Ops note [F] |
| Title: "on track for the March rate increase" | Not supported. None of the inputs shows that the 600 additional certified assemblers will be in place by March 1. | [A], [F] |
Headline: Not ready for March 1 on the current plan: 600 more certified assemblers needed, none confirmed by that date B: reframed
Not comparable: each region defines "certified" differently (US: LMS courses completed; UK: on-the-job assessor sign-off; France: training, medical fitness and supervisor authorisation), so this slide shows no single company-wide percentage.
Questions to settle before December 3 (all unknown from the inputs): C: decisions
Claude found every planted problem and did the date math the slide skipped. Its answer was right and too long for a ten-minute slot. Claire's edits are all judgment calls about the room she's walking into.
Use it before you present anything someone else assembled: a QBR deck, a regional roll-up, a board slide.
I'm the [your role] at a [industry] company with about [number] people in [regions]. [Who] built the [slide / deck] below from [the sources]. I'm presenting it to [audience] on [date], and they want one answer: [their question]. Before I put my name on it, I need you to check it.
Please give me: 1. Claim check (a table with each claim, what the sources actually support, and which source shows it); 2. What the slide leaves out that [audience] should see; 3. A rewritten slide (a headline, up to four bullets, and one line on anything that can't be compared).
Be skeptical. Read every slide, including the appendices. Check that numbers measure the same thing before you combine or compare them, check what each trend is compared against, and check dates and lead times against the deadline. If something is missing, say it's missing. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
Copy the prompt, then inputs [A] to [F], into one message in a new chat. Everything here is fictional and safe to paste.
I'm the VP of Learning & Development at an aerospace manufacturer with about 24,000 people in the US, the UK and France. My analyst built the roll-up slide below from three regional decks. I'm presenting it to our executive leadership team on December 3, and they want one answer: is the workforce certified and ready for a production rate increase on March 1? Before I put my name on this slide, I need you to check it. Please give me: 1. Claim check: a table with each claim on the slide, what the regional decks actually support, and which deck and slide shows it. 2. What the slide leaves out that the leadership team should see. 3. A rewritten slide: a headline, up to four bullets, and one line on anything that can't be compared. Be skeptical. Read every slide, including the appendices. Check that numbers measure the same thing before you combine or compare them, check what each trend is compared against, and check dates and lead times against the deadline. If something is missing, say it's missing. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs. [A] Email from Martin Hale, Chief HR Officer Subject: ELT Dec 3 — certification readiness Claire, you have 10 minutes on Dec 3. The ELT wants one answer: is the workforce certified and ready for the March 1 rate increase? One slide please. Operations is counting on 600 additional certified structures assemblers by March 1. [B] Roll-up slide, drafted by Ravi Menon, L&D analyst Title: Certified workforce: 91%, on track for the March rate increase - 21,730 of 24,000 employees certified = 91% across all regions - Up 7 points since Q1 (84%) - US 95% · UK 84% · France 89% - 380 new assemblers start January 12 to support the rate increase - No major risks Chart: Q1 84% → Q3 91% Notes from Ravi: "Built from the three regional decks. France total = 89% x 5,000." [C] US regional deck (Q3), summary of slides Slide 2: Headcount 12,000. Certified 11,400 = 95%. Slide 3: Definition: certified = all required courses for the role completed in the LMS. Slide 4: Trend: Q1 86% · Q2 94% · Q3 95%. Slide 5–8: Course completion by site. Slide 9 (appendix): NDT inspection. Level 2 inspectors certified: 11 of 19 required. Four of the eleven expire in January. External Level 3 examiner for recertification: none booked yet. [D] UK regional deck (Q3), summary of slides Slide 1: Headcount 7,000. Certified 5,880 = 84%. Slide 2: Definition: certified = signed off on the job by a qualified skills assessor (authorised stamp holder). Slide 3: Trend: Q1 80% · Q2 86% · Q3 84%. Slide 4: Note: 2 of our 5 skills assessors on long-term leave since August. Sign-off backlog: 410 people trained and waiting for assessment. [E] France regional deck (Q3), summary of slides Slide 1: Headcount 5,000 across three sites. Slide 2: Definition: certified (habilitation) = training complete + medical fitness + written authorisation from the supervisor. Slide 3: Toulouse and Méaulte: 3,204 of 3,600 certified = 89%. Slide 4: Saint-Nazaire (1,400 people): data not yet received. Slide 5: Trend (two reporting sites): Q1 85% · Q2 88% · Q3 89%. [F] Note from Operations planning Rate increase March 1 needs 600 additional certified structures assemblers. Hiring: 380 new assemblers start January 12 (US 240, UK 140). The structures assembly certification programme takes 10 weeks from start date. Remaining 220 to come from cross-training existing staff (plan not yet finalised).I'm the VP of Learning & Development at an aerospace manufacturer with about 24,000 people in the US, the UK and France. My analyst built the roll-up slide below from three regional decks. I'm presenting it to our executive leadership team on December 3, and they want one answer: is the workforce certified and ready for a production rate increase on March 1? Before I put my name on this slide, I need you to check it.
Please give me:
Be skeptical. Read every slide, including the appendices. Check that numbers measure the same thing before you combine or compare them, check what each trend is compared against, and check dates and lead times against the deadline. If something is missing, say it's missing. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
Subject: ELT Dec 3 — certification readiness
Claire, you have 10 minutes on Dec 3. The ELT wants one answer: is the workforce certified and ready for the March 1 rate increase? One slide please. Operations is counting on 600 additional certified structures assemblers by March 1.
Title: Certified workforce: 91%, on track for the March rate increase
Chart: Q1 84% → Q3 91%
Notes from Ravi: "Built from the three regional decks. France total = 89% x 5,000."
Slide 2: Headcount 12,000. Certified 11,400 = 95%. Slide 3: Definition: certified = all required courses for the role completed in the LMS. Slide 4: Trend: Q1 86% · Q2 94% · Q3 95%. Slide 5–8: Course completion by site. Slide 9 (appendix): NDT inspection. Level 2 inspectors certified: 11 of 19 required. Four of the eleven expire in January. External Level 3 examiner for recertification: none booked yet.
Slide 1: Headcount 7,000. Certified 5,880 = 84%. Slide 2: Definition: certified = signed off on the job by a qualified skills assessor (authorised stamp holder). Slide 3: Trend: Q1 80% · Q2 86% · Q3 84%. Slide 4: Note: 2 of our 5 skills assessors on long-term leave since August. Sign-off backlog: 410 people trained and waiting for assessment.
Slide 1: Headcount 5,000 across three sites. Slide 2: Definition: certified (habilitation) = training complete + medical fitness + written authorisation from the supervisor. Slide 3: Toulouse and Méaulte: 3,204 of 3,600 certified = 89%. Slide 4: Saint-Nazaire (1,400 people): data not yet received. Slide 5: Trend (two reporting sites): Q1 85% · Q2 88% · Q3 89%.
Rate increase March 1 needs 600 additional certified structures assemblers. Hiring: 380 new assemblers start January 12 (US 240, UK 140). The structures assembly certification programme takes 10 weeks from start date. Remaining 220 to come from cross-training existing staff (plan not yet finalised).