A CRO at a 5,600-person packaging maker checks whether last year's price increase stuck before the board plans another, with any AI chat her company allows.
A short email from the CEO, a confident summary from pricing, finance's net prices by segment and two notes from sales operations. The headline average is right. What it measures is the question.
Here the AI checks a headline average that is arithmetically right. The prompt makes it split price from mix before it agrees anything went up.
Use the AI tool your company approves: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
Copy the prompt and the four fictional inputs from the appendix into one message.
Take food & beverage: $2,000 to $2,030 a tonne is 1.5%. Then decide what the board hears first.
I'm Chief Revenue Officer at a packaging manufacturer that sells to food, personal care and industrial customers. Our CEO wants my view on whether last year's 4% price increase "stuck", because the board wants to plan another 3% this year on the strength of it. The board pre-read goes out Thursday, January 28, and the board meets Thursday, February 4. Today is Tuesday, January 19. Below are the CEO's email, the pricing team's summary, finance's net price data by segment and two sales operations notes.
Please give me:
Separate price from mix: compare like for like before you say anything stuck. Check the arithmetic. Don't count anything twice. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Exactly as it came back, not edited. Read it the way Nathalie did: check each point against the source it cites.
Short answer: the 4% did not stick. On a like-for-like basis, net invoice prices rose by about 1.7 to 1.8%, so we kept about 44% of the increase. That is before the $1.9M of FY26 rebates. Most of the reported 4.1% rise in average price per tonne comes from a mix shift towards personal care, which carries higher prices.
| Claim | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| List prices up 4.0%, effective Monday, February 2, 2026 | Unverified | No list price data in the inputs. Only the pricing summary [2] says this. Feb 2, 2026 is a Monday. Sales ops [4] counts exceptions from "February to December 2026", which suggests January FY26 sales were at old prices. That is an assumption: the fiscal year is not defined. |
| Average price $2,186 vs $2,100, up 4.1% | Holds arithmetically | From finance [3]: FY26 revenue $214.19M / 98,000 t = $2,185.6; FY25 $210.0M / 100,000 t = $2,100.0; +4.08%. found |
| "The increase stuck" | Doesn't hold | Like for like, every segment's net price rose by only 1.5 to 2.0% [3]. Most of the 4.1% is mix (see 2 and 3). found |
| Volume down only 2% (98,000 vs 100,000) | Holds in total, misleading | Food & beverage fell 13.3% (60,000 to 52,000 t). Personal care rose 25% and industrial 5% [3]. found |
| Segment | FY25 $/t | FY26 $/t | Change | Share of 4% kept |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Food & beverage | 2,000 | 2,030 | +$30, +1.5% | 37.5% |
| Personal care | 3,000 | 3,060 | +$60, +2.0% | 50% |
| Industrial | 1,500 | 1,530 | +$30, +2.0% | 50% |
Overall, like for like (FY26 tonnes at FY25 prices):
Splitting the $86/t average rise:
Things I did not add or count twice:
| What to confirm | Who |
|---|---|
| FY25 rebates in total and by segment, and the final FY26 rebate by segment (the FY26 rebates are being paid now) | Finance C: by Monday |
| Fiscal year dates, and whether January 2026 was billed at old prices | Finance |
| That the 4.0% list increase applied to all segments and customers, and any exempted contracts or price-locked agreements | Pricing |
| Churn list: tonnes, segments and FY25 prices of the six customers, and whether anyone left in other segments | Customer success / Sales ops |
| What drove personal-care growth (+5,000 t) and the remaining 1,500 t food & beverage decline | Sales ops / regional sales |
| The discount exceptions by segment in $, to confirm the $2.4M split | Sales ops |
Claude found every planted problem, split price from mix and noticed that FY25 rebates were missing too. It also flagged that the 1.75% might not be a real price gain. Nathalie's edits decide what the CEO reads first, put that limit on the page, and give finance a date.
Use it whenever someone reports that an average went up: price per unit, deal size, revenue per customer, margin per order.
I'm [your role] at a [industry] company that sells to [your segments]. [Who] wants my view on whether [the change] worked, because [the decision that depends on it]. [The deadline]. Today is [date]. Below are [the summary, the data by segment, and notes on discounts, rebates and customers lost].
Please give me: 1. Each claim in the summary: holds, doesn't hold, or unverified, with the input that shows it. 2. How much of [the change] we actually kept, by segment and overall, with your calculation. 3. What the overall figures hide. 4. What must be confirmed before [the deadline], and by whom. 5. My recommendation to [who], in five lines or fewer.
Separate price from mix: compare like for like before you say anything stuck. Check the arithmetic. Don't count anything twice. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Copy the prompt, then all four inputs, into one message in a new chat. Everything here is fictional and safe to paste.
I'm Chief Revenue Officer at a packaging manufacturer that sells to food, personal care and industrial customers. Our CEO wants my view on whether last year's 4% price increase "stuck", because the board wants to plan another 3% this year on the strength of it. The board pre-read goes out Thursday, January 28, and the board meets Thursday, February 4. Today is Tuesday, January 19. Below are the CEO's email, the pricing team's summary, finance's net price data by segment and two sales operations notes. Please give me: 1. Each claim in the pricing summary: holds, doesn't hold, or unverified, with the input that shows it. 2. How much of the price increase we actually kept, by segment and overall, with your calculation. 3. What the overall figures hide. 4. What must be confirmed before the pre-read, and by whom. 5. My recommendation to the CEO on the 3% plan, in five lines or fewer. Separate price from mix: compare like for like before you say anything stuck. Check the arithmetic. Don't count anything twice. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so. [1] Email from Luc Bernier, CEO Nathalie, pricing says last year's 4% increase stuck. The board wants to plan another 3% for FY27 on the strength of it. Can you check it before the pre-read goes out on the 28th? [2] Pricing team summary (FY26 price increase) - List prices up 4.0%, effective Monday, February 2, 2026. - Average price per tonne: $2,186 in FY26 against $2,100 in FY25, up 4.1%. The increase stuck. - Volume down only 2%: 98,000 tonnes against 100,000. [3] Finance: net invoice price by segment (after discounts, before year-end rebates) | Segment | FY25 tonnes | FY25 $/tonne | FY26 tonnes | FY26 $/tonne | |---|---|---|---|---| | Food & beverage | 60,000 | 2,000 | 52,000 | 2,030 | | Personal care | 20,000 | 3,000 | 25,000 | 3,060 | | Industrial | 20,000 | 1,500 | 21,000 | 1,530 | FY26 year-end volume rebates of $1.9M, mostly food & beverage, are paid in January 2027 and are not in these figures. [4] Sales operations notes - 38 discount exceptions were approved between February and December 2026, worth $2.4M in total; 31 were food & beverage. They are already in the net invoice prices above. - Customer success churn list: 6 food & beverage customers left in FY26 and named price as the reason. Their FY25 volume was 6,500 tonnes.I'm Chief Revenue Officer at a packaging manufacturer that sells to food, personal care and industrial customers. Our CEO wants my view on whether last year's 4% price increase "stuck", because the board wants to plan another 3% this year on the strength of it. The board pre-read goes out Thursday, January 28, and the board meets Thursday, February 4. Today is Tuesday, January 19. Below are the CEO's email, the pricing team's summary, finance's net price data by segment and two sales operations notes.
Please give me:
Separate price from mix: compare like for like before you say anything stuck. Check the arithmetic. Don't count anything twice. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Nathalie, pricing says last year's 4% increase stuck. The board wants to plan another 3% for FY27 on the strength of it. Can you check it before the pre-read goes out on the 28th?
| Segment | FY25 tonnes | FY25 $/tonne | FY26 tonnes | FY26 $/tonne |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Food & beverage | 60,000 | 2,000 | 52,000 | 2,030 |
| Personal care | 20,000 | 3,000 | 25,000 | 3,060 |
| Industrial | 20,000 | 1,500 | 21,000 | 1,530 |
FY26 year-end volume rebates of $1.9M, mostly food & beverage, are paid in January 2027 and are not in these figures.