I'm Director of Leadership Development at an energy equipment maker with about 40,000 people in 15 countries. Our CHRO wants one page on whether our Emerging Leaders Program works, for the annual talent review on December 8. Today is November 23. Below are his email, the programme team's summary, HR's cohort data and a 360 feedback summary.
Please give me:
1. Does the evidence show the programme works? Two sentences.
2. Each claim in the programme team's summary: what it compares, and whether it holds.
3. What we can honestly tell the talent review.
4. What evidence we'd need to know whether it works.
Check who is in each group being compared, who is missing from the numbers, whether each time window is complete, and how many people each figure rests on. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
[1] Email from Henrik Dahl, CHRO
Subject: Emerging Leaders, for the talent review
Amara, I'd like to tell the talent review that Emerging Leaders works. Can you give me one page on the evidence by December 1?
[2] Summary from the programme team
Graduates are promoted at 3x the rate of their peers! 41% of graduates were promoted within 18 months, against 14% of all managers. Results in Asia were exceptional: 83% promoted.
[3] Cohort data from HR
| Cohort | Selected | Graduated | Did not graduate | Graduates promoted within 18 months |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 (graduated June 2024) | 30 | 24 | 6 (4 left the company, 2 withdrew) | 11 |
| 2024 (graduated June 2025) | 28 | 22 | 6 (3 left the company, 3 withdrew) | 8 |
Who is selected: managers rated high potential in the annual talent review.
High-potential managers not in the programme, same period: 34 of 90 promoted within 18 months.
Asia, both cohorts: 5 of 6 graduates promoted.
[4] 360 feedback summary
Average 360 score: 3.6 before the programme, 4.1 after (out of 5). Before: all 46 graduates. After: 12 graduates completed it.