A VP Sales in a pumps and valves division decides whether six more reps will close next year's gap, with any AI chat her company allows.
A one-line question from the CRO, a confident hiring request from two regional directors, two short notes from sales operations and one from finance. The request adds up neatly. The data underneath points somewhere else.
Here the AI tests a request before you weigh it. The prompt asks whether the proposed fix matches what's actually limiting results.
Use the AI tool your company approves: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
Copy the prompt and the five fictional inputs from the appendix into one message.
Multiply six reps by the first-year bookings of recent hires, and compare it with $36M. Then decide what to do first.
I'm VP Sales for North America in an industrial equipment division. Two regional directors have asked for six more sales reps to close the gap to next year's bookings plan. Our CRO and CFO want my recommendation on Friday, December 11. Today is Wednesday, December 9. Our fiscal year is the calendar year. Below are the CRO's email, the hiring request, sales operations data and a finance note.
Please help me work through the decision:
Check whether the proposed solution fits the real problem before you compare options. Check the arithmetic and the dates. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Exactly as it came back, not edited. Read it the way Grace did: check each point against the source it cites.
Here is how I'd work through the decision. Assumptions are marked as assumptions. Every number comes from your five inputs or from simple arithmetic on them.
| Claim in the request | What the inputs show | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity $245M | Finance: 48 seats x $5.1M = $244.8M, rounded to $245M [5]. But only 45 seats are filled, and the 3 empty ones have had no candidates since September [4]. 45 x $5.1M = $229.5M. | Overstated by about $15M. It counts 3 seats nobody is sitting in. found |
| Gap $35M | $280M plan - $245M = $35M. On 45 filled seats: $280M - $229.5M = $50.5M. | The real gap is about $50M, if FY26 productivity holds in FY27 (assumption). |
| $6.0M per new rep | $6.0M is the FY25 figure, and it's quota, not bookings. FY26 bookings per rep were $5.1M [3]. Finance's capacity uses $5.1M. | The request uses one rate for the gap and a different, higher one for the fix. found |
| Six reps add $36M | Even six fully productive reps at $5.1M would be $30.6M. New hires actually booked $1.8M each in their first 12 months [3]. | $36M is not supported by any figure in the data (see section 2). found |
| "Gap closed" | Even at $36M it doesn't close a $50.5M gap. | No. |
Two other points:
Headcount is not the clearest limit. The data points to four other things:
Things I can't tell from the inputs:
| Option | Possible FY27 add | Cost | What's uncertain |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Hire six as requested | About $7.7M at most, likely less | About $1.1M in FY27, $1.56M a year after | Time to hire (backfills stalled), ramp shape, budget not approved |
| B. Fill the 3 backfills first (not proposed by anyone) | About $3.9M at most if they start by April (3 x about $1.3M); more if sooner | Seats are already approved. Whether they're budgeted is not stated (assumption that they are). | No candidates since September. Needs a recruiting fix (agency, referral bonus, revised profile). None of those costs are in the data. |
| C. Assign the 310 accounts to named owners in January (not proposed by anyone) | Unknown. If bookings returned even part way from $9M toward FY25's $22M, it could be worth several million. Needs owners for the full year. | Little new cost (assumption). Possible comp or territory changes. | Why the accounts declined. Whether current reps have room. Effect on reps' existing accounts. |
| D. Find and fix the productivity drop (not proposed by anyone) | Each $0.1M per rep across 45 reps = $4.5M. Back to $6.0M = $40.5M (not realistic in one year, illustrative only). | Unknown until the cause is known | Cause unknown. Could be ramp mix, territory, market, or process. |
| E. Restate the plan or the gap to the CRO and CFO | No bookings added | None | Whether the plan can move |
| F. Staged hiring (not proposed by anyone) | Little in FY27, mostly FY28 | Spend only when conditions are met | Depends on the recruiting fix working |
Even B, C and D together are not shown by the data to close $50.5M in FY27. That needs saying plainly on Friday.
Don't approve six new reps on the current evidence. Keep the request open until the issues below are tested. found
What to say:
What would change this recommendation:
Data to bring Friday, or to ask Sales Ops for:
Claude found every planted problem and didn't swap one quick fix for another. It also misread one line. Grace's edits correct that, keep one action conditional, and put dates on the rest.
Use it whenever someone asks for more of something to close a gap: more reps, more engineers, more budget, more stores, more shifts.
I'm [your role] in [your company or division]. [Who] has asked for [the request] to close [the gap]. [Who] wants my recommendation on [date]. Today is [date]. Our fiscal year is [the fiscal year]. Below are [the request, the data on productivity, ramp, hiring time, seats and coverage, and the cost].
Please help me work through the decision: 1. The request's arithmetic: check each number and where it comes from. 2. What [the request] would really add in [the year], given [the hiring time and ramp] in the data. 3. What's actually limiting [results], from the data. Is [headcount] the real limit? 4. The options, including any nobody has proposed, each with what it would add, what it costs and what's uncertain. 5. My recommendation, with the conditions that would change it.
Check whether the proposed solution fits the real problem before you compare options. Check the arithmetic and the dates. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Copy the prompt, then all five inputs, into one message in a new chat. Everything here is fictional and safe to paste.
I'm VP Sales for North America in an industrial equipment division. Two regional directors have asked for six more sales reps to close the gap to next year's bookings plan. Our CRO and CFO want my recommendation on Friday, December 11. Today is Wednesday, December 9. Our fiscal year is the calendar year. Below are the CRO's email, the hiring request, sales operations data and a finance note. Please help me work through the decision: 1. The request's arithmetic: check each number and where it comes from. 2. What six new reps would really add in FY27, given the hiring time and ramp in the data. 3. What's actually limiting bookings, from the data. Is headcount the real limit? 4. The options, including any nobody has proposed, each with what it would add, what it costs and what's uncertain. 5. My recommendation to the CRO and CFO, with the conditions that would change it. Check whether the proposed solution fits the real problem before you compare options. Check the arithmetic and the dates. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so. [1] Email from Peter Haines, CRO Grace, Dan and Kim want six more reps to close the FY27 gap. Ruth and I need your recommendation on Friday. Is hiring the answer? [2] Hiring request (Dan Moretti and Kim Sato, regional directors) FY27 bookings plan: $280M. Our capacity: $245M. Gap: $35M. Six more reps at a $6.0M quota each adds $36M. Gap closed. We'd like approval this week so we can start recruiting. [3] Sales operations: productivity and ramp - Bookings per rep: FY25 $6.0M, FY26 $5.1M. - The 11 reps hired in FY25 and FY26 booked an average of $1.8M each in their first 12 months. - Average time from hiring approval to a new rep's start date: 4 months. [4] Sales operations: seats and accounts - 48 approved rep seats; 45 are filled. The 3 empty seats are backfills for reps who left. They've been open since September, with no candidates yet. - 310 accounts have had no assigned rep since their reps left early in FY26. Those accounts booked $22M in FY25 and $9M in FY26. [5] Finance note Capacity = 48 seats x $5.1M = $245M. A new rep costs $260K a year, fully loaded. There is no FY27 budget for new headcount unless Ruth approves it.I'm VP Sales for North America in an industrial equipment division. Two regional directors have asked for six more sales reps to close the gap to next year's bookings plan. Our CRO and CFO want my recommendation on Friday, December 11. Today is Wednesday, December 9. Our fiscal year is the calendar year. Below are the CRO's email, the hiring request, sales operations data and a finance note.
Please help me work through the decision:
Check whether the proposed solution fits the real problem before you compare options. Check the arithmetic and the dates. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Grace, Dan and Kim want six more reps to close the FY27 gap. Ruth and I need your recommendation on Friday. Is hiring the answer?
FY27 bookings plan: $280M. Our capacity: $245M. Gap: $35M. Six more reps at a $6.0M quota each adds $36M. Gap closed. We'd like approval this week so we can start recruiting.
Capacity = 48 seats x $5.1M = $245M. A new rep costs $260K a year, fully loaded. There is no FY27 budget for new headcount unless Ruth approves it.