I'm the L&D manager for a business unit of about 9,000 people in 11 manufacturing plants. Our BU president asked whether new hires aren't ready because of training, and wants one page for his operations review on December 2. Below are his email, our LMS onboarding export, HR hiring and turnover data, and notes from two plant HR business partners.
Please give me:
1. The answer to his question in two sentences.
2. What the numbers really show: onboarding, early turnover and readiness, with the input each point comes from.
3. Plant 4's request: should we approve it, and why or why not.
4. What I need from the president: no more than three asks.
Be skeptical. Check what each number counts and who it leaves out, compare small counts with rates, and separate training problems from staffing, pay or schedule problems. If something is missing, say it's missing. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
[1] Email from Tom Hargrove, BU President
Subject: New hires
Marcus, every plant manager tells me new hires aren't ready when they hit the floor. Is training the problem? Give me one page for the Dec 2 ops review: what's going on and what you need from me.
[2] LMS export: new-hire onboarding, July to October
New-hire onboarding completion: 96% (412 of 429)
Completion = pre-start online modules (safety orientation videos, 2.5 hours), assigned at offer acceptance.
Report shows active learners only. Learners who leave during the period are removed.
Week-4 on-the-job skills check: recorded in plant binders, not in the LMS.
[3] HR data: hires and early leavers, July to October
| | Hires | Left within 90 days | % |
|---|---|---|---|
| All 11 plants | 520 | 187 | 36% |
| Plant 4 Ridgeway | 140 | 74 | 53% |
Exit survey, top reasons (all plants): mandatory overtime or schedule 41% · pay 22% · "felt unprepared / no buddy on the floor" 18% · other 19%.
[4] Note from the Plant 4 Ridgeway HR business partner
Plant manager wants a new two-week classroom onboarding programme before anyone touches a line, because "new hires aren't ready". For context: we've run 12-hour shifts with mandatory overtime since August because we're 38 operators short of the staffing plan. Our two lead trainers have been working on the line since September to cover gaps.
[5] Note from the Plant 9 Lakeview HR business partner
Good month! Onboarding completion 100%, and turnover is way down: only 4 early leavers in October. (We hired 6 in October under the hiring freeze.)