I'm Head of L&D for North America at an industrial equipment maker. I want to replace a five-day Supervisor Academy at one plant with on-the-floor coaching. The plant's general manager wants to keep it, and we meet one to one for 30 minutes on Thursday, November 19. Today is November 16. Below are his email, the plant's data, my draft proposal, a supervisor survey and an email I sent him last year.
Please help me prepare:
1. What each of us needs from this meeting.
2. His likely arguments: which ones the data supports, which it doesn't, and how I answer each one honestly.
3. Where he has a point: anything in my own proposal or past commitments I should fix or concede.
4. An opening I can say in under a minute.
Be fair to him. Check his claims and mine with the same rigour, and tell me if my proposal doesn't fit the problem. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
[1] Email from Tom Kessler, General Manager, Akron
Subject: Supervisor Academy
Lena, I hear you want to scrap the Supervisor Academy. It's the best thing we've done here. Incidents are down 40% since we started it, and my supervisors aren't quitting anymore. And you promised it through 2027. Let's talk Thursday.
[2] Akron data from HR and EHS
Supervisor Academy: started September 2025. Five days off-site. $180,000 a year.
Recordable incidents: 2024: 30. 2025: 18 (January to August: 12; September to December: 6).
EHS note: new machine guarding installed on all presses in January 2025.
Supervisors who left: September 2024 to August 2025: 4 of 22. September 2025 to August 2026: 4 of 24.
[3] My draft proposal
Replace the Academy with on-the-floor coaching: two internal coaches work alongside supervisors on day shift. First-year cost $95,000, including $40,000 one-time coach certification. Saves $125,000 a year.
[4] Akron supervisor pulse survey, June 2026
13 of 24 supervisors responded. 8 said they want "more coaching on the floor."
Shift pattern: 16 day-shift supervisors, 8 night-shift supervisors.
[5] My email to Tom, November 2025
Glad the Academy is working for you. We'll fund it at Akron through December 2027.