I'm Chief Revenue Officer at an automotive components maker. Our largest customer wants a three-year price freeze plus exclusivity to renew its contract. Our CEO wants my decision page by Thursday, January 21, before I meet the customer on Wednesday, January 27. Today is Monday, January 18. Below are the customer's letter, the account P&L, their draft exclusivity clause, a note from our VP Sales, and notes from finance and legal.
Please help me work through the decision:
1. Each claim in the customer's letter and our VP Sales's note: supported, contradicted or unverified, with the input that shows it.
2. What the account really earns today and under a three-year freeze, with your calculation.
3. What exclusivity would really cover, based on the clause as written.
4. The options: concede, walk, and any option nobody has proposed, each with what it gains, what it risks and what's uncertain.
5. My recommendation to the CEO, with what would change it and who must confirm what before January 27.
Check whether the choice we've been given is the real choice before you compare options. Read the clause as written, not as described. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
[1] Letter from Greg Tanner, Head of Purchasing, Corvane Motors
For the 2027–2029 brake assembly award, we require two things: prices frozen at 2026 levels for three years, and exclusivity as set out in the attached clause. In return, Narrowgate keeps the award. Fennick has offered us 8% below your price.
[2] Corvane account P&L, FY26 (finance)
- Revenue at list price: $220.0M.
- Gross margin at list: 24% ($52.8M).
- Rebates and volume discounts: 7% of list ($15.4M), booked on a separate line.
- Narrowgate total revenue, FY26: $700M.
[3] Exclusivity clause (Corvane's draft)
"Supplier shall not supply brake assemblies, or components for brake assemblies, to any other vehicle manufacturer or its tier-1 suppliers in North America during the term."
[4] Note from Carla Ruiz, VP Sales, North America
"We can't lose Corvane: it's 30% of our revenue. Exclusivity only touches the two smaller automakers we sell brake assemblies to directly, $38M a year. The options are to concede both or walk."
[5] Finance note (January 15)
- Revenue from brake components sold to tier-1 suppliers in North America, FY26: $64M (net).
- Steel and aluminium contracts reset each January. 2027 forecast: cost of goods for Corvane products up 4%.
- Silao labour agreement: wages up 5% from July 1, 2027. Not yet costed by product.
[6] Legal note (January 15)
An exclusivity clause that covers tier-1 suppliers may raise competition law questions. We need outside counsel's view before agreeing to any exclusivity. Not yet requested.