A CRO at a 7,200-person automotive components maker decides how to answer his largest customer's demand for a price freeze plus exclusivity, with any AI chat his company allows.
A short letter from the customer, the account P&L, the clause itself, a note from the VP Sales, and notes from finance and legal. The VP Sales describes the clause. The clause says something else.
Here the AI works through a decision that arrives framed as two options. The prompt makes it test the framing before comparing anything.
Use the AI tool your company approves: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
Copy the prompt and the six fictional inputs from the appendix into one message.
It says components and tier-1 suppliers. Ask which of the $64M of tier-1 sales it covers. Then decide what the CEO reads first.
I'm Chief Revenue Officer at an automotive components maker. Our largest customer wants a three-year price freeze plus exclusivity to renew its contract. Our CEO wants my decision page by Thursday, January 21, before I meet the customer on Wednesday, January 27. Today is Monday, January 18. Below are the customer's letter, the account P&L, their draft exclusivity clause, a note from our VP Sales, and notes from finance and legal.
Please help me work through the decision:
Check whether the choice we've been given is the real choice before you compare options. Read the clause as written, not as described. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Exactly as it came back, not edited. Read it the way Daniel did: check each point against the source it cites.
No. The inputs show two separate asks, a price freeze and exclusivity. Nothing in them says Corvane will only accept both together; the letter states its position, and a buyer's opening position is not its walk-away. Carla's framing also leaves out the obvious third path: a counter-proposal that splits the two asks. And it rests on a misreading of the clause (see section 3). So the real decision for January 27 is what we offer, not whether we sign or leave.
There is also a timing gap. The award covers 2027–2029 and today is January 18, so 2027 has already started. The steel and aluminium contracts reset this month. The inputs don't say when the current contract ends or when new prices would take effect. Assumption: the 2027 cost increase applies to the whole award period.
| Claim | Source | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price frozen "at 2026 levels" | Letter [1] | Unverified (undefined) | The letter doesn't say whether this means list price ($220.0M) or net price after the 7% rebates ($204.6M) [2]. That is a $15.4M a year difference in what we would be freezing. |
| "Fennick has offered us 8% below your price" | Letter [1] | Unverified | No input supports it. "Your price" is also undefined. 8% below list = $202.4M, only about 1.1% below our current net of $204.6M. 8% below net = $188.2M. Very different threats. Nothing tells us whether Fennick's offer is like-for-like on scope, volume or terms. found |
| "Narrowgate keeps the award" | Letter [1] | Unverified / incomplete | No volume, share or minimum commitment is stated. Exclusivity binds only us [3]; Corvane commits to nothing in return. |
| Corvane is "30% of our revenue" | VP Sales [4] | Roughly supported, basis unclear | $220.0M list ÷ $700M = 31.4%. $204.6M net ÷ $700M = 29.2%. We don't know whether the $700M is on a list or net basis [2], so "about 30%" holds, but neither figure is exact. found |
| Exclusivity "only touches the two smaller automakers… $38M a year" | VP Sales [4] | Contradicted | The clause [3] covers "any other vehicle manufacturer or its tier-1 suppliers" and "components for brake assemblies". Finance [5] shows $64M (net) of brake components sold to tier-1 suppliers in North America. That is outside Carla's figure. found |
| "The options are to concede both or walk" | VP Sales [4] | Contradicted / unsupported | Nothing in the inputs rules out a counter-proposal or splitting the two asks. found |
| (Implied) we can agree exclusivity | — | Contradicted | Legal [6]: we need outside counsel before agreeing to any exclusivity, and counsel has not yet been asked. |
FY26 today [2]
So the account earns about $37.4M of gross margin, not $52.8M. Gross margin is before overheads; the inputs don't show operating profit.
Under a three-year freeze at 2026 net price
Assumptions: flat volumes, rebates stay at 7%, and the freeze applies to net price.
If we matched Fennick (8% below)
As written [3]:
Revenue exposed, at least: $38M (direct automakers [4]) + $64M (tier-1 components [5]) = $102M a year. That is about half of Corvane's net revenue. D: total not yet known
Caveats:
A. Concede both (freeze plus clause as drafted)
B. Walk
C. Counter: split the asks (the option nobody proposed) B: no capacity promise
D. Price concession only, no exclusivity This is a variant of C if Corvane pushes hard on price. Finance must first set a floor price below which the account no longer pays its way, including labour and the 2028–29 material resets.
Don't concede both, and don't walk, on the current evidence. Go to the January 27 meeting with option C: found
The decision page should state plainly:
What would change this:
Who must confirm what before January 27
Assumptions used: flat volumes; rebates stay at 7%; freeze applies to net price; no overlap between the $38M and the $64M. The 4% a year material increase for 2028–29 is illustrative only.
Claude found every planted problem, read the clause as written and proposed the counter nobody had. Daniel's edits keep an assumption off the CEO's page, take out a promise no input supports, give finance a date, and stop short of a total the inputs don't establish.
Use it whenever a decision arrives framed as two choices: concede or walk, build or buy, hire or don't.
I'm [your role] at a [industry] company. [Who] wants [their terms]. [Who decides] wants my decision page by [date], before [the meeting], [date]. Today is [date]. Below are [the letter or request, the account numbers, the contract wording, our team's view, and finance and legal notes].
Please help me work through the decision: 1. Each claim: supported, contradicted or unverified, with the input that shows it. 2. What the account really earns today and under [their terms], with your calculation. 3. What [the clause] would really cover, based on the wording. 4. The options, including any nobody has proposed, each with what it gains, risks and leaves uncertain. 5. My recommendation, with what would change it and who must confirm what before [date].
Check whether the choice we've been given is the real choice before you compare options. Read the clause as written, not as described. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Copy the prompt, then all six inputs, into one message in a new chat. Everything here is fictional and safe to paste.
I'm Chief Revenue Officer at an automotive components maker. Our largest customer wants a three-year price freeze plus exclusivity to renew its contract. Our CEO wants my decision page by Thursday, January 21, before I meet the customer on Wednesday, January 27. Today is Monday, January 18. Below are the customer's letter, the account P&L, their draft exclusivity clause, a note from our VP Sales, and notes from finance and legal. Please help me work through the decision: 1. Each claim in the customer's letter and our VP Sales's note: supported, contradicted or unverified, with the input that shows it. 2. What the account really earns today and under a three-year freeze, with your calculation. 3. What exclusivity would really cover, based on the clause as written. 4. The options: concede, walk, and any option nobody has proposed, each with what it gains, what it risks and what's uncertain. 5. My recommendation to the CEO, with what would change it and who must confirm what before January 27. Check whether the choice we've been given is the real choice before you compare options. Read the clause as written, not as described. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so. [1] Letter from Greg Tanner, Head of Purchasing, Corvane Motors For the 2027–2029 brake assembly award, we require two things: prices frozen at 2026 levels for three years, and exclusivity as set out in the attached clause. In return, Narrowgate keeps the award. Fennick has offered us 8% below your price. [2] Corvane account P&L, FY26 (finance) - Revenue at list price: $220.0M. - Gross margin at list: 24% ($52.8M). - Rebates and volume discounts: 7% of list ($15.4M), booked on a separate line. - Narrowgate total revenue, FY26: $700M. [3] Exclusivity clause (Corvane's draft) "Supplier shall not supply brake assemblies, or components for brake assemblies, to any other vehicle manufacturer or its tier-1 suppliers in North America during the term." [4] Note from Carla Ruiz, VP Sales, North America "We can't lose Corvane: it's 30% of our revenue. Exclusivity only touches the two smaller automakers we sell brake assemblies to directly, $38M a year. The options are to concede both or walk." [5] Finance note (January 15) - Revenue from brake components sold to tier-1 suppliers in North America, FY26: $64M (net). - Steel and aluminium contracts reset each January. 2027 forecast: cost of goods for Corvane products up 4%. - Silao labour agreement: wages up 5% from July 1, 2027. Not yet costed by product. [6] Legal note (January 15) An exclusivity clause that covers tier-1 suppliers may raise competition law questions. We need outside counsel's view before agreeing to any exclusivity. Not yet requested.I'm Chief Revenue Officer at an automotive components maker. Our largest customer wants a three-year price freeze plus exclusivity to renew its contract. Our CEO wants my decision page by Thursday, January 21, before I meet the customer on Wednesday, January 27. Today is Monday, January 18. Below are the customer's letter, the account P&L, their draft exclusivity clause, a note from our VP Sales, and notes from finance and legal.
Please help me work through the decision:
Check whether the choice we've been given is the real choice before you compare options. Read the clause as written, not as described. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
For the 2027–2029 brake assembly award, we require two things: prices frozen at 2026 levels for three years, and exclusivity as set out in the attached clause. In return, Narrowgate keeps the award. Fennick has offered us 8% below your price.
"Supplier shall not supply brake assemblies, or components for brake assemblies, to any other vehicle manufacturer or its tier-1 suppliers in North America during the term."
"We can't lose Corvane: it's 30% of our revenue. Exclusivity only touches the two smaller automakers we sell brake assemblies to directly, $38M a year. The options are to concede both or walk."
An exclusivity clause that covers tier-1 suppliers may raise competition law questions. We need outside counsel's view before agreeing to any exclusivity. Not yet requested.