I'm VP of Talent at a logistics company with about 18,000 people in 60 warehouses in the US and Canada. Peak season is starting. Our SVP of Operations wants to cut new-hire onboarding from three days to one, to get people on the floor faster. My CHRO wants my view by Thursday. Below are her email, our onboarding report, the SVP's note, our 30-day turnover figures and a safety note.
Please give me:
1. Does cutting onboarding solve the problem Operations describes? Answer in two sentences.
2. What the numbers really show, with the input each point comes from.
3. A counter-proposal I can take to Operations.
Be skeptical. Check what each number counts, whether a change is a trend or a season, where the time actually goes, and what we would lose by cutting. If something is missing, say so. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
[1] Email from Janet Cole, CHRO
Subject: Ops onboarding proposal
Renee, Dan wants to cut onboarding from 3 days to 1 for peak. He says onboarding is the bottleneck and our onboarding clearly isn't working, given turnover. Your view by Thursday please.
[2] Onboarding report, October
| Region | Hires | Onboarding completions | % |
|---|---|---|---|
| East | 1,240 | 1,302 | 105% |
| Central | 980 | 902 | 92% |
| West | 860 | 791 | 92% |
Note: a completion is counted each time someone finishes the programme. People who leave and are rehired in the same month are counted again.
Site 51 (Moncton) has not submitted onboarding data since June.
[3] Note from Dan Reyes, SVP Operations
Offer to first shift is 9 days on average. Onboarding is 3 of those. Cut it to 1 and we get people on the floor 2 days faster for peak.
Breakdown: offer to background check cleared, 5 days; check cleared to onboarding start, 1 day; onboarding, 3 days.
[4] HR analytics: people who leave within 30 days
August 18% · September 21% · October 27%
Analyst note: "30-day turnover rising sharply. Onboarding isn't working."
Footnote: October includes peak-season temporary hires on 6-week contracts, counted as leavers when the contract ends.
[5] Safety note, October
22 recordable injuries in the network. 14 involved people in their first 30 days. Day 2 of onboarding is the warehouse safety day (powered equipment, lifting, pedestrian routes).