I'm Chief Revenue Officer at an industrial automation company that sells annual service contracts and software subscriptions. Three leaders have each proposed a different way to own renewals: sales keeps them, customer success takes them, or a dedicated renewals team. I have to recommend one to our CEO and CFO on Thursday, March 11, with what it costs. Today is Tuesday, March 2. Below are the CEO's email, the three proposals, last year's renewal data, the pay notes and a note from our VP Customer Success.
Please give me:
1. A like-for-like table of the three options: what each claim measures (contracts or dollars), the period and accounts it covers, and the full yearly cost, including pay changes, for 2027 and from 2028.
2. Each option tested against the data.
3. What's missing that I'd need to decide well.
4. My recommendation, including whether any option is proven well enough to choose now, and what must be confirmed, by whom, before March 11.
5. A five-line summary for the CEO and CFO.
Put every option on the same measure, period and cost basis before you compare them, and say plainly if none is proven as proposed. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
[1] Email from Andrew Hale, CEO
Helena, renewals slipped to 88% last year and I'm getting three different answers on who should own them. Please bring Sofia and me one recommendation on March 11, with what it costs.
[2] The three proposals (one-line summaries from each author)
| Option | Proposed by | Claim | Cost stated |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Sales keeps renewals, with a richer incentive | Mark Ellison, VP Sales | Renewal commission for account executives goes from 2% to 2.5% of renewed value. "Retention rises from 88% to 92%." | About $1.3M a year |
| B. Customer success takes renewals | Priya Nair, VP Customer Success | "Our pilot retained 95% against sales' 88%." Hire 8 customer success managers (CSMs) at $140K each. | $1.12M a year |
| C. A dedicated renewals team | Revenue operations | 10 renewal managers at $150K each. "Dedicated renewal teams achieve 94% (industry benchmark, vendor report)." | $1.5M a year |
[3] Renewal data, 2026 (revenue operations)
- Renewal base: 1,200 annual contracts worth $300M. All renew once a year.
- Sales-owned: 1,100 contracts, $288M. Renewed: 1,001 contracts and $253.4M.
- Customer success pilot: 100 contracts, each under $250K a year, all due July to December 2026, $12.0M. Renewed: 95 contracts and $10.2M (5 lost, $0.6M; downgrades at renewal, $1.2M).
- The 60 largest contracts (each over $1M) are $132M of the base. None was in the pilot.
[4] Pay notes (HR compensation)
- Today account executives earn 2% of renewed value.
- Option B: CSMs earn a 1% bonus on renewed value. Account executives keep their 2% for 2027 "so they support the hand-over"; it ends in 2028.
- Option C: renewal managers earn 1.5% of renewed value. Account executives stop earning on renewals from January 2028.
[5] Note from Priya Nair, VP Customer Success
"Customers tell my team they'd rather renew with the people who help them every day than with a salesperson they see once a year. The pilot proves it."