I'm VP Sales for the US South at an industrial pump maker. We need sales coverage in Texas and Oklahoma from the second quarter, and our Chief Commercial Officer wants my recommendation at the commercial review on Thursday, January 14. Today is Tuesday, January 5. Below are his email, our sales forecast for the territory, two distributor proposals, the cost of hiring our own reps, and our channel policy.
Please give me:
1. A comparison table: each option, what it costs at our own year-one forecast (the same basis for all three), what it offers, and what our policy says about it.
2. Evidence or promise? Which claims in the proposals are evidence and which are promises.
3. What's missing that I'd need before deciding.
4. My recommendation, with a one-line reason. If none fits as proposed, say so, and say what would make one fit.
Compare costs on our forecast, not the partners' claims. Keep evidence of results apart from cost. Check each option against the policy. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
[1] Email from Mike Brennan, Chief Commercial Officer
Marcus, we need coverage in Texas and Oklahoma from Q2. You have three options on the table. Bring me a recommendation for the commercial review on the 14th.
[2] Sales operations: territory forecast
Year-one Halden sales in Texas and Oklahoma: $3.0M base case (range $2.2M to $3.8M), based on 2026 quote requests from the territory.
[3] Proposal from Northgate Supply
Commission: 12% of Halden's net sales in the territory. "We'll deliver $8M in year one." "120 active industrial accounts" (account list attached: 45 in Texas or Oklahoma, the rest in Louisiana and New Mexico). Term: 2 years, non-exclusive.
[4] Proposal from Kellan Industrial
Kellan buys from Halden at 18% off list price and resells at list. 60 accounts, all in Texas and Oklahoma. Kellan also carries Brayford pumps. Requires a 5-year exclusive agreement.
[5] Note from HR: direct hires
Three territory sales reps at $165,000 loaded cost each per year. Halden's 2025 hires took about 9 months to reach full productivity.
[6] Halden channel policy (extract)
Initial distributor terms are limited to 2 years. Exclusivity needs board approval. A partner may not carry a directly competing line in the same product category without a CCO waiver. Brayford pumps compete directly with Halden in this category.