I'm VP Sales for key accounts at an electrical equipment maker. We're raising prices 9% from January 1, and our largest customer is threatening to move volume to a competitor. I'm meeting their head of procurement for 45 minutes on Thursday, December 3. Today is December 1. Below are her email, our account summary, a note from our pricing team, the competitor quote she forwarded, and an email my predecessor sent her in January.
Please help me prepare:
1. What each of us needs from this meeting.
2. Her arguments: which ones hold, which don't, and how I answer each one honestly.
3. Where she has a point: what we should concede or fix.
4. My one clear ask, and the point where I'd stop and take it back to my team.
5. An opening I can say in under a minute.
Be fair to her. Check her claims and ours with the same rigour, compare the two offers like for like, and don't guess at her motives. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs.
[1] Email from Karen Liu, Head of Procurement, Northfield Grid Services
Subject: Your 2027 price increase
Sam, a 9% increase is unacceptable. Ridgeline has quoted us 12% below your current price for the same panels. Your deliveries have been unreliable all year. And you promised us a 3% loyalty rebate last year that we've never seen. We need our first 2027 panels in February. Unless you hold prices, we'll move our 2027 volume to Ridgeline.
[2] Northfield account summary, from our CRM
2026 orders: 1,240 panels, $18.6M ($15,000 a panel, delivery and commissioning included; $900 of that is delivery and commissioning).
On-time delivery in 2026: 81% (our target is 95%). Third quarter: 74%.
Our lead time: 10 weeks. Our warranty: 5 years.
[3] Note from our pricing team
Steel and copper costs are up 11% a panel. Materials are 60% of a panel's cost. The 9% increase covers our cost increase.
[4] Ridgeline quote, forwarded by Karen
Panel price: $13,200. Excludes delivery and commissioning. Warranty: 2 years. Lead time: 20 weeks from order. Price firm for up to 500 panels.
[5] Email from my predecessor to Karen, January 2026
If Northfield's 2026 volume exceeds 1,200 panels, we'll pay a 3% loyalty rebate on 2026 orders in the first quarter of 2027.