A CRO at a 58,000-person industrial automation company compares three proposals for who owns renewals before she meets the CEO and CFO, with any AI chat her company allows.
A short email from the CEO, three one-line proposals, last year's renewal data, HR's pay notes and a note from the VP Customer Success. Every proposal has a strong number. None says what it counts.
Here the AI compares three proposals that each count success their own way. The prompt makes it use one measure and one cost basis first.
Use the AI tool your company approves: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot.
Copy the prompt and the five fictional inputs from the appendix into one message.
$10.2M kept of $12.0M is 85%. Compare it with sales' $253.4M of $288M. Then decide what you take to the CEO.
I'm Chief Revenue Officer at an industrial automation company that sells annual service contracts and software subscriptions. Three leaders have each proposed a different way to own renewals: sales keeps them, customer success takes them, or a dedicated renewals team. I have to recommend one to our CEO and CFO on Thursday, March 11, with what it costs. Today is Tuesday, March 2. Below are the CEO's email, the three proposals, last year's renewal data, the pay notes and a note from our VP Customer Success.
Please give me:
Put every option on the same measure, period and cost basis before you compare them, and say plainly if none is proven as proposed. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Exactly as it came back, not edited. Read it the way Helena did: check each point against the source it cites.
Basis used throughout (my assumptions, please confirm):
Retention, both ways (from the 2026 data):
| Group | Contracts renewed | Dollars renewed |
|---|---|---|
| Sales-owned (1,100 contracts, $288M) | 1,001 of 1,100 = 91.0% | $253.4M of $288M = 88.0% |
| CS pilot (100 contracts, $12.0M) | 95 of 100 = 95.0% | $10.2M of $12.0M = 85.0% |
| Whole company (1,200 contracts, $300M) | 1,096 of 1,200 = 91.3% | $263.6M of $300M = 87.9% |
The pilot's arithmetic checks out: $12.0M − $0.6M lost − $1.2M downgraded = $10.2M.
Options. Today's renewal pay is 2% × $263.6M = $5.27M a year.
| A. Sales keeps renewals | B. Customer success takes them | C. Dedicated renewals team | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claim | 88% → 92% | "95% vs sales' 88%" | 94% |
| What the claim measures | Probably dollars (88% matches sales' dollar rate). Measure for 92% not stated. | Mixed. 95% is the pilot's contract rate; 88% is sales' dollar rate. | Not stated (vendor report) found |
| Period and accounts | A forecast. No period or basis given. | 100 contracts, each under $250K, due July to December 2026 only. None of the 60 largest. | Industry benchmark, not our accounts. Period and sample unknown. |
| Like-for-like figure | No evidence | 85% in dollars vs sales' 88% (or 95% vs 91% in contracts) | None from our data |
| Cost as stated | ~$1.3M | $1.12M | $1.5M |
| Full yearly cost, 2027 | 2.5% × 263.6 = $6.59M (+$1.32M vs today) | AE 2% $5.27M + CSM 1% $2.64M + 8 × $140K $1.12M = $9.03M (+$3.76M) | AE 2% $5.27M + renewal managers 1.5% $3.95M + 10 × $150K $1.50M = $10.73M (+$5.45M) found |
| Full yearly cost, from 2028 | $6.59M (+$1.32M) | $2.64M + $1.12M = $3.76M (−$1.52M vs today) | $3.95M + $1.50M = $5.45M (+$0.18M) |
Notes on cost:
A. Sales keeps renewals, 2.5% commission.
B. Customer success takes renewals.
C. Dedicated renewals team.
None of the three is proven as proposed. found
What I'd recommend on March 11:
To confirm before March 11 (ideally by Friday, March 5): C: three asks
Claude put every claim on the same measure, found the pay each proposal left out and said none is proven. It doubted the customer claim but never asked for the customers' view. Helena's edits add it, take out the fallback, and cut the asks to three.
Use it whenever several teams propose competing fixes for the same number: who owns renewals, which channel gets the budget, which team takes a segment.
I'm [your role] at a [industry] company. [Several teams] have each proposed a different way to [solve the problem]. I have to recommend one to [who] on [date], with what it costs. Today is [date]. Below are [their email, the proposals, the results data, the pay or cost notes and any other notes].
Please give me: 1. A like-for-like table of the options: what each claim measures, the period and accounts it covers, and the full yearly cost, including pay changes. 2. Each option tested against the data. 3. What's missing that I'd need to decide well. 4. My recommendation, including whether any option is proven well enough to choose now, and what must be confirmed, by whom, before [date]. 5. A five-line summary for [who].
Put every option on the same measure, period and cost basis before you compare them, and say plainly if none is proven as proposed. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Copy the prompt, then all five inputs, into one message in a new chat. Everything here is fictional and safe to paste.
I'm Chief Revenue Officer at an industrial automation company that sells annual service contracts and software subscriptions. Three leaders have each proposed a different way to own renewals: sales keeps them, customer success takes them, or a dedicated renewals team. I have to recommend one to our CEO and CFO on Thursday, March 11, with what it costs. Today is Tuesday, March 2. Below are the CEO's email, the three proposals, last year's renewal data, the pay notes and a note from our VP Customer Success. Please give me: 1. A like-for-like table of the three options: what each claim measures (contracts or dollars), the period and accounts it covers, and the full yearly cost, including pay changes, for 2027 and from 2028. 2. Each option tested against the data. 3. What's missing that I'd need to decide well. 4. My recommendation, including whether any option is proven well enough to choose now, and what must be confirmed, by whom, before March 11. 5. A five-line summary for the CEO and CFO. Put every option on the same measure, period and cost basis before you compare them, and say plainly if none is proven as proposed. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so. [1] Email from Andrew Hale, CEO Helena, renewals slipped to 88% last year and I'm getting three different answers on who should own them. Please bring Sofia and me one recommendation on March 11, with what it costs. [2] The three proposals (one-line summaries from each author) | Option | Proposed by | Claim | Cost stated | |---|---|---|---| | A. Sales keeps renewals, with a richer incentive | Mark Ellison, VP Sales | Renewal commission for account executives goes from 2% to 2.5% of renewed value. "Retention rises from 88% to 92%." | About $1.3M a year | | B. Customer success takes renewals | Priya Nair, VP Customer Success | "Our pilot retained 95% against sales' 88%." Hire 8 customer success managers (CSMs) at $140K each. | $1.12M a year | | C. A dedicated renewals team | Revenue operations | 10 renewal managers at $150K each. "Dedicated renewal teams achieve 94% (industry benchmark, vendor report)." | $1.5M a year | [3] Renewal data, 2026 (revenue operations) - Renewal base: 1,200 annual contracts worth $300M. All renew once a year. - Sales-owned: 1,100 contracts, $288M. Renewed: 1,001 contracts and $253.4M. - Customer success pilot: 100 contracts, each under $250K a year, all due July to December 2026, $12.0M. Renewed: 95 contracts and $10.2M (5 lost, $0.6M; downgrades at renewal, $1.2M). - The 60 largest contracts (each over $1M) are $132M of the base. None was in the pilot. [4] Pay notes (HR compensation) - Today account executives earn 2% of renewed value. - Option B: CSMs earn a 1% bonus on renewed value. Account executives keep their 2% for 2027 "so they support the hand-over"; it ends in 2028. - Option C: renewal managers earn 1.5% of renewed value. Account executives stop earning on renewals from January 2028. [5] Note from Priya Nair, VP Customer Success "Customers tell my team they'd rather renew with the people who help them every day than with a salesperson they see once a year. The pilot proves it."I'm Chief Revenue Officer at an industrial automation company that sells annual service contracts and software subscriptions. Three leaders have each proposed a different way to own renewals: sales keeps them, customer success takes them, or a dedicated renewals team. I have to recommend one to our CEO and CFO on Thursday, March 11, with what it costs. Today is Tuesday, March 2. Below are the CEO's email, the three proposals, last year's renewal data, the pay notes and a note from our VP Customer Success.
Please give me:
Put every option on the same measure, period and cost basis before you compare them, and say plainly if none is proven as proposed. Check the arithmetic. Don't add facts that aren't in the inputs; if you assume something, say so.
Helena, renewals slipped to 88% last year and I'm getting three different answers on who should own them. Please bring Sofia and me one recommendation on March 11, with what it costs.
| Option | Proposed by | Claim | Cost stated |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Sales keeps renewals, with a richer incentive | Mark Ellison, VP Sales | Renewal commission for account executives goes from 2% to 2.5% of renewed value. "Retention rises from 88% to 92%." | About $1.3M a year |
| B. Customer success takes renewals | Priya Nair, VP Customer Success | "Our pilot retained 95% against sales' 88%." Hire 8 customer success managers (CSMs) at $140K each. | $1.12M a year |
| C. A dedicated renewals team | Revenue operations | 10 renewal managers at $150K each. "Dedicated renewal teams achieve 94% (industry benchmark, vendor report)." | $1.5M a year |
"Customers tell my team they'd rather renew with the people who help them every day than with a salesperson they see once a year. The pilot proves it."